R.B. stood up, and went straight on to the attack.
“So, Inspector, when you searched my client’s premises, you found plenty of spare copies of the Racing Rodent’s cards?”
“No.”
“No? Is that no, you didn’t find any cards, or no, you didn’t search his premises?”
“Mr Tree stated that he lives near a coffee shop in Pacific, Missouri. A mansion known as the ‘Tree House’.”
“Pacific, Missouri?”
“It is a small town in the United States, sir. A railway line was begun there towards the Pacific Ocean, in 1853, hence the name. I wrote to the Sheriff of Pacific, sir, and he was kind enough to inform me that there is no Coffee Shop and no Tree House. I challenged Mr Tree on the subject and he said…he said that nothing in the centre of Pacific survived the fire of 1891.”
“The fire of 1891. Seventeen years in the future.”
“I can only repeat what he told me, sir.”
“But he told it as though it was an historic fact.”
“Forgive me, sir, but he spoke of a Boeing 747 as though it is a historic fact. Mr Tree has a vivid imagination, and he appears to believe that by making up stories about the future he will avoid the consequences of his criminality in the present.”
“So you have noted inconsistencies in his account of the future?”
“No, he is too clever for that.”
“Surely, if he was clever, he wouldn’t rely on some fantasy about the future? Actually, inspector, he is either very clever, or…..” he paused, “or he is telling the truth!”
Cries of ‘Rubbish!’ and ‘Does he think the jury were born yesterday?’ until Old Dutch banged his much overused gavel.
R.B continued. “How, Inspector, have you demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt that my client stole the Venus Verticordia?”
Slave’s voice was forceful, his tone slightly condescending, “because I caught him in possession of it and he has yet to furnish me with a satisfactory explanation of how he came by it!”
“Unless he really did purchase it in in 2016?”
Slave remained silent, regarding R.B. with a pitying stare.
Fife pointed out, “Inspector, you are bound to answer Counsel’s questions.”
“Very well, my Lord. The suggestion is totally ridiculous. Time travel is impossible.”
“And yet, my client has ‘made up’ a total and consistent history between now and 2016.”
“Oh come, sir. War with Germany? Twice? Unthinkable. Atomic bombs that can destroy entire cities? Ridiculous. Men flying to the moon? Laughable. He even informed me that women would get to vote for their Members of Parliament! That one day, the United Kingdom would get a female Prime Minister, by the name of ‘Mrs Thatcher’!”
By now even the judge was howling with laughter. Wragg was sobbing with mirth. Even Barb had to admit that there was no chance of a woman prime minister, any more than a woman Pope.
R.B. could see that he was getting nowhere. He’d tried, God knew he’d tried. But, to be honest, he didn’t really believe it himself.
Once the court had settled down, he asked Slave, “Please would you summarise the reasons that you believe my client to be the murderer of Miss Brown.”
“I will. He takes size 12 shoes, he likes crucified women, and he has no alibi.”
“Did you establish whether Dorothy Brown was known to my client?”
“He claims never to have heard of her.”
“I see. How common are size 12 shoes?”
“Pardon?”
“It is a simple question, Inspector. How common are size 12 shoes?”
“I…I don’t know. Not very, I should think.”
“May I ask, who in this court wears size 12 shoes, other than my client?”
Half a dozen men raised their hands, including two members of the jury. And the Earl of Cruxton.
“And who likes crucified women?”
No hands were raised. Including the Earl’s, though Barb knew bloody well that he loved to play crux with her. She’d been on a cross in the dungeon only yesterday. She let it go – that, too, would have been grounds for divorce.
The Earl leaned towards her, and whispered, “Before you ask, I was visiting Jollyrei in Gloucestershire. I checked my diary.”
“So, no-one likes crucified women,” continued RB. “at least, no-one is proud enough of the fact to advertise it here. But, in fact, for all you and I know, a liking for crucified women could be at least as common as size 12 shoes. Can you assure me that isn’t so, Inspector?”
“I should very much doubt…..”
“I’m not asking for your doubts, Inspector, I am asking for your absolute assurance that there aren’t as many men in this court who like crucified women as those who take size 12 shoes?”
Even the judge looked uncomfortable.
“I must press you, Inspector. Can you give me that assurance?”
Slave looked at him with fury. “No, sir, I cannot give you that assurance.”
“Thank you, Inspector. One final point, if I may. You have told my learned friend the Counsel for the Prosecution what you did on the morning of the 12th February, 1869. What did you do on the evening of the 11th?”
“I beg your pardon?”
“I asked you what you did on the evening before Miss Brown’s crucified body was discovered?”
Madiosi stood up. “My Lord, is this question relevant? Inspector Slave is not on Trial for Miss Brown’s murder!”
Fife looked at R.B. “Mr Barrington-Smythe, what is your point, exactly?”
“My point, my Lord, is that my client is not the only person in this court who cannot give an explanation of his whereabouts on February 11th 1869! But I think my point is made, so I have no further questions.”
The remainder of the trial passed with less excitement. Jollyrei told the court of how he had heard noises in the night, and come downstairs to find that the Venus Verticordia had been replaced by a picture of a squirrel. He described in graphic detail how inconsolably upset his wife, the Lady Thessela, had become on discovering the theft. The shock had been so bad that she had required smelling salts. She was prone to fits of sobbing to this day, it had unsettled her completely.
Other owners told similar stories, and then Rossetti and Eulalia both confirmed Tree’s ‘demands’ that he be furnished with a painting of a crucified woman, and that he had been prepared to pay nearly £200 for it.
The only material witness who didn’t place a hand on the Bible and swear an oath was the Countess of Cruxton. The Earl’s cash had seen to that, in one way or another.
The Jury was out for a day and a half. One and a half nail biting days.
Eventually, the court reassembled. Roland Rattington let the Jury in, and he was asked, “Gentlemen of the jury, have you reached verdicts upon which you are all agreed?”
“We have.”
“On the charge that, on the night of May 12th past, the defendant, Theodore Hiram Tree, did wilfully and maliciously steal a painting known as the ‘Venus Verticordia’ from the home of Lord and Lady Jollyrei of Owlage Manor, Gloucestershire, how do you find the defendant? Guilty, or Not Guilty?”
Rattington took a deep breath.
“Guilty.”