Joseph Madiosi, QC, then took Inspector Slave through all the other art thefts; in every case he and Slave, working as a well-tuned double act, were at pains to ensure that the Jury were only too well aware of the common thread running through all the threads, to wit; the card bearing the image of a squirrel, the trademark of the infamous ‘Racing Rodent.’
By the time they were done, eleven of the twelve men of the Jury were entirely convinced that the prisoner before them was the Racing Rodent.
The twelfth was more than content to let them go on thinking that.
Madiosi paused for effect, then he cleared his throat. “Inspector Slave, would you be so kind as to tell the court what you found in Shoreditch on the morning of 12th February, 1869?”
“I will do my best, sir. I must ask the court’s forgiveness if I need to pause at times, as some of the details of this case are…unpleasant.” He made a bit of a show of mopping his brow with his handkerchief.
Lord Justice Fife was sympathetic. “Take your time, inspector. The court realises how distressed you must have been.”
“Thank you, milord. The sexton of St Leonard’s Church, Shoreditch, rose early on the morning of 12th February. He had a grave to dig for a funeral on the 13th, and he noticed as he rose that the night had been a cold one, with frost upon the ground. He realised that the ground would be harder to dig, so he made haste to the church in order to begin his task. Upon arriving at the church he was met by a fearful sight. At some point after 9:30pm the previous evening, when the vicar had left the church after saying Compline, and 7:30am, when the sexton arrived, a large wooden cross had been erected in the churchyard. Upon the cross was the body of a young woman, completely naked, with fair hair and big ti…er…nails sticking out of her wrists and feet. The sexton discovered quickly that the victim was deceased, and he made haste to alert the local constable.
“I reached the scene within the half hour. Hearing that I was to see a young woman upon a cross, I had to steel myself for the ordeal, but my duty lay in that churchyard, and to that churchyard I went.”
“Very commendable, Inspector,” commented Fife. “A true public servant always puts his duty above any other consideration.”
“Yes, indeed, milord. It was a terrible sight. Nails. A grotesque parody of the death of our Lord. Terrible. I still see her in my dreams at night, her naked body, her smiling face….”
“Smiling?” interrupted Fife again. “Surely the poor woman wasn’t smiling?”
“Indeed she was milord. That is the strangest, most unsettling thing about the whole thing. She was smiling. I gave me the creeps, I can assure you, milord.”
“Were you able to identify the victim?” Madiosi finally managed to take over questioning from the judge.
“Eventually, yes. Mrs Fanshawe, who runs a boarding house in Virginia Road, identified her as one of her tenants, a Miss Dorothy Rose Brown, from Leeds in Yorkshire. She had only been staying with Mrs Fanshawe for a few days, hoping I expect to make her fortune in London. Except that she met her cross instead.”
“And was there a racing rodent card on the cross?”
“No, there was not, this was before the art thefts began. However, this is a most unusual form of homicide, and Mr Rossetti, in his statement, gave me to understand that Mr Tree was, ah, interested in crucifixion.”
“Upon what, pray, did he base that conclusion?”
“Upon the fact that Mr Tree commissioned from him a painting of a woman on a cross!”
The court erupted as Slave uttered this. Cries of “Shame!” “Disgusting!” “Ghastly!” “Pervert!” rang out. “The scoundrel should be horsewhipped before he is hung!” shouted one man. He got cheered for that.
Fife let it go on for a few seconds, before bringing the court to order.
“Pray continue, Inspector.”
“The perpetrator of the crucifixion of Miss Brown had inadvertently stepped in the earth of a freshly filled in grave, which hadn’t frozen….”
“They have a lot of burials in that churchyard, don’t they?”
“Well, it is Shoreditch, milord. As I was saying, footprints. We measured them and made a cast of them. The shoe size is that of Mr Tree.”
More murmurings, though this time Old Dutch brought the court to order with a glare.
“I therefore challenged Mr Tree, inviting him to share with me his whereabouts on the night of the 11th and 12th February.”
“And?” prompted Madiosi.
“And all I got was the same old poppycock about how he was born in 1965 so how could he be expected to provide an alibi for nearly a hundred years before he was born.” Slave rolled his eyes.
“So, let me see if I have understood you, Inspector. We have a callous, cruel, and slightly unusual murder. Death by crucifixion. We have a suspect who, witnesses declare, is interested in the crucifixion of young women. We have physical evidence putting the suspect at the scene. And the suspect positively declines to provide a reasonable alibi.”
“That is correct, sir.”
Madiosi cast a meaningful glance at the jury, then sat. “No further questions, my lord.”
Old Dutch peered at Counsel for the Defence over his half-moon glasses. “Your witness, Mr Barrington-Smythe.”